227 S. Division Street Zelienople, PA, 16063 andrew@beneighgroup.com
Your Neighborhood Insurance Agent |

Claims & Carriers

Trusted Carrier Partners

Insurance Carriers & Policyholder Resources

As an independent insurance agency, Beneigh Insurance Group works with a variety of respected insurance carriers so we can help clients find coverage suited to their individual needs. If you need help with a claim, policy question, or coverage concern, we encourage you to start with our local team. Direct carrier contact information is also available below whenever you need it.

Have a claim or a question about your policy?

Start with Beneigh Insurance Group. We can help you understand the next step, assist with the claims process, and help you communicate with your carrier when needed.

Talk With an Expert

Erie Insurance

Erie Insurance provides personal and commercial insurance solutions including auto, home, business, and life coverage. Known for its independent-agent model and service-focused approach, Erie gives policyholders access to local guidance along with direct claims and billing support.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Prefer to contact Erie directly? Use the phone numbers and carrier resources below.

Claims 1 (800) 367-3743
Billing / Service 1 (800) 458-0811, option 5
File Directly With Erie Pay Erie Bill Visit Erie Website

Travelers Insurance

Travelers offers a broad range of personal, business, and specialty property and casualty insurance products. Policyholders can manage billing, report claims, and access service through Travelers' online tools while continuing to work with an independent insurance professional.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Prefer to contact Travelers directly? Use the policyholder resources below.

Claims 1 (800) 252-4633
Policy Service 1 (888) 564-5043
File Directly With Travelers Pay Travelers Bill Visit Travelers Website

The Hartford

The Hartford provides insurance solutions for individuals and businesses, including auto, home, commercial insurance, workers' compensation, and other specialty coverages. Customers have access to online account, billing, and claims tools in addition to direct telephone support.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

The Hartford uses different service teams for personal and business policies.

Auto / Home Claims 1 (800) 243-5860
Auto / Home Service 1 (877) 896-9320
Business Claims 1 (800) 327-3636
Business Service 1 (866) 467-8730
File Directly With The Hartford Pay Hartford Auto / Home Bill Visit The Hartford Website

Utica National Insurance Group

Utica National provides personal and commercial insurance through independent agents, including home, auto, business, and workers' compensation coverage. Policyholders can use Utica National's customer care tools for payments, account access, claims reporting, and policy service.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Prefer to contact Utica National directly? Use the carrier resources below.

Claims 1 (800) 216-1420
Service / Payment 1 (800) 598-8422
File Directly With Utica National Pay Utica National Bill Visit Utica National Website

GEICO

GEICO is a national insurer best known for automobile coverage and also provides access to additional personal insurance products. Its digital service tools allow policyholders to manage payments, access policy information, and report or track claims online and through mobile tools.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Prefer to contact GEICO directly? Use the carrier resources below.

Claims 1 (800) 841-3000
Sales / Service 1 (800) 207-7847
File Directly With GEICO Pay GEICO Bill Visit GEICO Website

Progressive Insurance

Progressive offers personal and commercial insurance products with a strong emphasis on auto, motorcycle, RV, and specialty vehicle coverage. Its online account and mobile tools give customers direct access to billing, policy information, roadside assistance, and claims services.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Prefer to contact Progressive directly? Use the policyholder resources below.

Claims 1 (800) 776-4737
Customer Service 1 (800) 776-4737
File Directly With Progressive Pay Progressive Bill Visit Progressive Website

Liberty Mutual Insurance

Liberty Mutual provides personal, commercial, and specialty insurance solutions for individuals and businesses. Customers can manage policies and billing online and access direct support for claims, payments, and other policyholder service needs.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Prefer to contact Liberty Mutual directly? Use the carrier resources below.

Claims 1 (800) 225-2467
Policy / Billing 1 (800) 290-8711
File Directly With Liberty Mutual Pay Liberty Mutual Bill Visit Liberty Mutual Website

Nationwide

Nationwide offers personal, business, agribusiness, and specialty insurance products. Policyholders have access to online and mobile services for account management, billing, insurance documents, and claims reporting and tracking.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Prefer to contact Nationwide directly? Use the policyholder resources below.

Claims 1 (800) 421-3535
Personal Service 1 (877) 669-6877
File Directly With Nationwide Pay Nationwide Bill Visit Nationwide Website

Openly

Openly focuses on homeowners insurance distributed through independent insurance agencies. Its service model combines agent guidance with digital tools and dedicated teams for policy, billing, and claims support.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Openly accepts claim reports online. Payment instructions and billing support are available through its service team.

Claims 1 (888) 808-4842, option 2
Service / Billing 1 (888) 808-4842, option 1
File Directly With Openly Openly Billing & Payment Information Visit Openly Website

Penn Charter Mutual Insurance Company

Penn Charter Mutual provides homeowners and dwelling insurance through independent agents in Pennsylvania. As part of the Lititz Mutual Group, it shares claims and administrative resources while maintaining a policyholder-focused mutual insurance structure.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Prefer to contact Penn Charter Mutual directly? Use the carrier resources below.

New Claims 1 (855) 725-5642
Service / Status 1 (800) 626-4751
Penn Charter Claim Information Pay Penn Charter Bill / Account Login Visit Penn Charter Website

Lititz Mutual

Lititz Mutual provides property and casualty insurance through independent agents with a strong focus on homeowners, dwelling, farm, and business coverage. As a mutual insurer, the company is organized around serving its policyholders and long-term agency relationships.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Prefer to contact Lititz Mutual directly? Use the carrier resources below.

New Claims 1 (855) 725-5642
Service / Status 1 (800) 626-4751
Lititz Mutual Claim Information Pay Lititz Mutual Bill / Account Login Visit Lititz Mutual Website

Agency Insurance Company (AIC)

Agency Insurance Company provides personal automobile, commercial automobile, motorcycle, and off-road vehicle insurance through independent agents. AIC offers direct claims reporting along with policyholder service and online account access.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Prefer to contact Agency Insurance Company directly? Use the carrier resources below.

Claims 1 (800) 841-5241
Customer Service 1 (800) 492-5629
AIC Claims & Contact Information Pay AIC Bill / Policyholder Login Visit AIC Website

Lemonade Insurance

Lemonade offers digital-first insurance products including renters, homeowners, auto, pet, and term life insurance. Policyholders can manage coverage and payment information online or in the Lemonade app, which is also the primary way to begin many claims.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Lemonade generally directs policyholders to its app for claims and online account tools for policy and payment management.

Customer Support 1 (844) 733-8666
Claims Use the Lemonade app or customer support
Lemonade Claim Information Lemonade Account / Payments Visit Lemonade Website

Bristol West Insurance

Bristol West specializes in personal automobile insurance and offers flexible coverage and payment options for a broad range of drivers. Customers can access policy information, make payments, and report or track claims through Bristol West's online services.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Prefer to contact Bristol West directly? Use the policyholder resources below.

Claims 1 (800) 274-7865
Service / Billing 1 (888) 888-0080
File Directly With Bristol West Pay Bristol West Bill Visit Bristol West Website

Foremost Insurance Group

Foremost specializes in coverage for a wide range of homes, vehicles, and specialty risks, including manufactured homes, motorcycles, RVs, rental properties, and other personal insurance needs. Policyholders have direct access to claims reporting, billing, and policy service resources.

File a Claim Talk With an Expert
Contact Information

Prefer to contact Foremost directly? Use the policyholder resources below.

Claims 1 (800) 527-3907
Policy Service 1 (800) 527-3905
Billing 1 (800) 532-4221
File Directly With Foremost Pay Foremost Bill / Account Login Visit Foremost Website

Not Sure Who You Need to Contact?

Beneigh Insurance Group can help you determine the right next step before you contact a carrier directly. Reach out to our local team and we'll help point you in the right direction.

Talk With an Expert
Image

Office Address

Find Us On Social Media!